- fix a bug in the MockDispatcher, when duplicating the ExitNodes.
A vector-ctor with curly braces will be interpreted as std::initializer_list
- add visualisation of the contents appearing at the end of the pipeline
*** something still broken here, increments don't happen as expected
`steam/engine/mock-dispatcher.hpp |cpp` now integrates this
''complete mock setup for render jobs and frame dispatching.''
The exising `DummyJob` has been slightly adapted and renamed
to `MockJob` and is tightly integrated with the other mocks.
The implementation of a `MockDispatcher` necessitated to change
the use of `MockJobTicket`. The initial attempts used a complete
mock implementation, but this approach turned out not to be viable.
Instead — based on the ideas developed for the mock setup —
now the prospective real implementation of `JobTicket` is available
and will be used by the mock setup too. Instead of a synthetic spec,
now a setup of recursively connected `ExitNode`(s) is used; the latter
seems to develop into some kind of Facade for the render node network.
Based on this mock setup, we can now demonstrate the (mostly) complete
Job-Planning pipeline, starting from a segmentation up to render jobs,
and verify proper connectivity and job invocation.
✔
- has to be prepared / supported by the RenderEnvironmentClosure
- actual translation happens when building the Dispatcher-Pipeline
- implementation delegate through
virtual size_t Dispatcher::resolveModelPort (ModelPort)
...ouch this was insidious: the STL implementation for list does not
return a pointer to the element just allocated, but rather retrieves
and dereferences the back() / front() iterator after returning from emplace_back|front()
...which in case of re-entrant allocations is something wildly different
than the initial allocation. Thus a *cheap* and dirty placeholder implementation
just using a STL container is not possible, and we need at least
to code up likewise cheesy placeholder implementation by hand.
- separate allocation and ctor all
- use an inline buffer in the STL container
- explicitly handle ctor failures to discard allocation
- NOT THREADSAFE and likely WASTFUL in terms of performance
==> MockSupport_test now back to GREEN after complete refactoring
The existing implementation of the Player from 2012~2015 inclduded
an additional differentiation by media channel (for multichannel media)
and would build a separate CalcStream for each channel.
The in-depth analysis conducted for the ongoing »Vertical Slice« effort
revealed that this differentiation is besides the point and would never
be materialised: Since -- by definition -- all media processing has
to be done by the engine, also the generation of the final output format
including any channel multiplexing will happen in render nodes.
The only exception would be when only a single channel of multichannel
media is extracted -- yet this case would then translate into a
dedicated ModelPort.
Based on this reasoning, a lot of complexity (and some contradictions)
within the JobTicket implementation can be removed -- together with
some further leftovers of the fist attempt to build JobTickets always
from a Mock specification (we now use construction by the Segment,
based on an ExitNode, which is the expected actual implementation
for production setup)
...by defining a new scheme for access to custom allocators
...and then passing a reference to such an accessor into the
JobTicket ctor, thereby allowing the ticket istelf recursively
to place further JobTicket instances into the allocation space
--> success, test passes (finally)
Up to now, a draft/mock implementation was used, relying on a »spec tuple«,
which was fabricated by MockJobTicket. But with the introduction of
NodeGraphAttachment, the MockSequence now generates a nested ExitNode structure,
and thus the JobTicket will be created through the "real" ctor, and
no longer via MockJobTicket.
Thus it is possible to skip this whole interspersed »spec tuple«,
since ExitNode *is* already this aggregated / abstracted Spec
PROBLEM: can not implement Spec-generation, since
- we must use a λ for internal allocation of JobTickets
- but recursive type inference is not possible
Will thus need to abandon the Spec-Tuple and relocate this
traversal-and-generation code into JobTicket itself
It turns out that the real (not mocked) implementation of JobTicket creation
is already required now for this planned (mock)Dispatcher setup;
moreover, this real implementation turns out to be almost identical
to the mock implementation written recently -- just nested structure
of prerequiste JobTickets need to be changed into a similar structur
of ExitNodes
-- as an aside: rearrange various tests to be more in-line
with the envisioned architecture of playback and engine
...this opens up yet another difficult question and a host of new problems
- how are prerequisites detected or arranged by the Builder
- how are prerequisites represented?
- what is an ExitNode in terms of implementation? A subclass of ProcNode?
- how will the actual implementation of JobTicket creation (on-demand) work?
- how to adapt the Mock implementation, while retaining the Specification
for Segments and prerequisites?
...which leads to the next daunting problems:
- we need some mocked ModelPort and DataSink placeholders
- we need a way how to inherit from a partial TreeExplorer pipeline
The prototypical setup of data structures and test support components
is largely complete by now — with the exception of the `MockDispatcher`,
which will be completed while moving to the next steps pertaining the
setup of a frame dispatch pipeline.
* the existing `DummyJob` was augmented to allow verification of
association between Job and `JobTicket`
* the existing implementation of `JobTicket` was verified and augmented
to allow coverage of the whole usage cycle
* a `MockJobTicket` was implemented on top, which can be generated
from a symbolical test specification (rather than from the real
Fixture data structure)
* a complete `MockSegmentation` was developed, allowing to establish
all the aforementioned data structures without an actual backing
Render Engine. Moreover, `MockSegmentation` can be generated
from the aforementioned symbolic test specification.
* as part of this work, an algorithm to split an existing Segmentation
and to splice in new segments was developed and verified
Last testcase: add deeply nested Prerequisites.
Turns out that the allocator must be able to handle
re-entrant allocations, which std::deque can not fulfil.
Thus using std::list here for the Mock implementation.
In the end, the real allocations will be done by our custom
allocator (AllocationCluster), which can be arranged easily
to support re-entrant allocation calls (since the whole point
is to just place those objects into a pre-allocated large block
and only de-allocate them later in one sway. Thus the allocator
does not need to wait for the object constructor to finish, which
trivially allows for re-entrant calls)
By reasoning and analysis I conclude that the differentiation into
multiple channels is likely misplaced in JobTicket; it belongs ratther
into the Segment and should provide a suitable JobTicket for each ModelPort
Handling of prerequisites also needs to be reshaped entirely after
switching to a pipeline builder for the Job-planning pipeline; as
preliminary access point, just add an iterator over the immediate
prerequisites, thereby shifting the exploration mechanism entirely
out of the JobTicket implementation
...now able to build a mock segmentation which issues dummy jobs,
and is wired such as to verify the right job is invoked for each segment.
And this allows to build and verify the Dispatcher,
without being able to invoke actual render jobs yet.
There are 12 distinct cases regarding the orientation of two intervals;
The Segmentation::splitSplice() operation shall insert a new Segment
and adjust / truncate / expand / split / delete existing segments
such as to retain the *Invariant* (seamless segmentation covering
the complete time axis)
- how to pass-in a specification given as GenNode
- now this might be translated into a MockJobTicket allocated in the MockSegmentation
Unimplemented: actually build the Segment with suitable start/end time
right now we're lacking a complete working implementation of render node invocation,
and thus the Dispatcher implementation can only be verified with the help
of mocked jobs. However, at least a preliminary implementation of tagging the
invocation instance is available, and thus we're able to verify that
a given job instance indeed belongs to and is "backed" by a specific JobTicket.
This is prerequisite for building up a (likewise mocked) Fixture datastructure,
and this in turn was meant to form the basis for attacking an actual Scheduler
implementation, followed by a real render node invocation.
...using the MockJobTicket setup as point of reference,
since the actual invocation of render nodes will only be drafted
later in this "Vertical Slice" integration effort...
- introduce a JobTicket::NOP (null-object pattern)
- assuming that the function splitSplice() will retain complete coverage allways
Remark:
`Fixture::getPlaylistForRender()` is a leftover from the very early implementation drafts.
This function was more or less based on the way Cinelerra works; it is clear by now
that Lumiera can not possibly work this way, given that we'll build a low-level model
and dispatch precompiled render jobs....
The Fixture and the low-level model backbone deserve a distinct namespace on their own.
Since it's built by the Builder from the Session contents, and also used by the frame dispatch,
we can expect dependence on some types from Steam-Layer, and thus this namespace
needs to reside in Steam-Layer rather, while the actual low-level Model
might become part of Vault-Layer, creating a hierarchy of data structures.
(Remark: likely also the session related namespaces will need a reorganisation)
The idea is to escape a "design deadlock" by using a test-driven prototype
implementation of the data structure to back a further development
of the Dispatcher and Scheduler implementation, which then can be used
to gradually elaborate and switch over to an actual implementation
data structure
...requires a first attempt towards defining a `JobTiket`.
This turns out quite tricky, due to using those `LinkedElements`
(intrusive single linked list), which requires all added records
actually to live elsewhere. Since we want to use a custom allocator
later (the `AllocationCluster`), this boils down to allocating those
records only when about to construct the `JobTicket` itself.
What makes matters even worse: at the moment we use a separate spec
per Media channel (maybe these specs can be collapsed later non).
And thus we need to pass a collection -- or better an iterator
with raw specs, which in turn must reveal yet another nested
sequence for the prerequisite `JobTickets`.
Anyhow, now we're able at least to create an empty `JobTicket`,
backed by a dummy `JobFunctor`....
Looks like we'll actually retain and use this low-level solution
in cases where we just can not afford heap allocations but need
to keep polymorphic objects close to one another in memory.
Since single linked lists are filled by prepending, it is rather
common to need the reversed order of elements for traversal,
which can be achieved in linear time.
And while we're here, we can modernise the templated emplacement functions
2023-04-20 18:53:17 +02:00
Renamed from tests/core/steam/engine/dispatcher-mock.hpp (Browse further)
